The "we already have an accountant" objection: what to say next
The "we already have an accountant" objection is the reply an accounting firm hears most often when it contacts a business owner. It is usually true: an established business tends to have someone doing its books, tax or year-end accounts already. So the objection is not really a no to you. It is a statement of fact, and often a polite way to end the conversation. This guide explains what the objection usually means, gives a four-step answer, offers scripts, and shows how switching really works.
The aim is not to talk anyone into leaving a firm they are happy with. It is to find out whether there is a gap, and to be the first name they think of when one appears.
What does "we already have an accountant" usually mean?
The same words can hide very different situations. Before you reply, work out which one you are dealing with.
| What they say | What it may mean | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| "We already have an accountant." (and nothing else) | A reflex to end a cold contact | Acknowledge it and ask one light question |
| "We’ve used the same firm for years." | Loyalty, or habit | Respect it; ask what they would change |
| "We’re happy with them." | Genuine satisfaction | Leave the door open; do not push |
| "They’re fine, but…" | A gap they have not acted on | Ask about the gap and offer a small next step |
| "It’s too much hassle to change." | Fear of the switching process | Explain how a handover works |
| "My accountant is a friend." | A personal relationship | Do not compete; offer a second opinion on one topic |
Your job in that moment is not to sell. It is to keep the conversation open long enough to learn which row applies.
How should you answer the objection?
Use the same four steps every time:
- Acknowledge. Agree that having an accountant is normal and sensible. This lowers their guard.
- Ask one question. Find out how well the current arrangement covers what they need now.
- Offer something small. A short call, a second opinion on one issue or a useful guide, not a full proposal.
- Agree a next step or a date. If there is no gap, ask when it would make sense to check in again.
The question in step two does most of the work. Ask about their business, not about their accountant.
What can you say? Scripts for email and phone
Adapt the wording and keep each reply short.
Email reply
"Thanks for letting me know, and it’s good that you’re well looked after. I’m not asking you to change anything. One question, if you have a moment: is there anything you’d like more of from your accountant this year, such as earlier tax estimates or help with cash flow? If not, I’ll leave it there. If yes, I’m happy to share a short note on how we handle it."
Phone
"That makes sense, most businesses your size do. Can I ask one thing before I let you go? When you have a question in the middle of the year, how quickly do you usually get an answer?"
If the answer is "it depends", ask what happens when it takes longer.
Which questions reveal a real gap?
Ask about outcomes the owner cares about, not about the other firm’s competence:
- "How early in the year do you know roughly what tax you will owe?"
- "Who do you ask when you’re deciding whether to hire or buy equipment?"
- "Do you get monthly or quarterly numbers, or only the year-end accounts?"
- "Which software do you use for bookkeeping, and does your accountant work in it with you?"
- "Has anything about the business changed recently, such as new staff, a new location or a new owner?"
- "If you could change one thing about how your accounts are handled, what would it be?"
Changes in the business are often the best opening. A firm that suited a sole trader may not suit a growing company with staff. That is not a criticism of anyone; it is a different need.
How do you handle "it’s too much hassle to change"?
Owners often imagine that switching means chasing records and starting from scratch. In practice, professional bodies set out how a change of accountant should work.
The ICAEW Code of Ethics, which applies to ICAEW members, has a section on professional appointments. It says that, "having been asked to accept an appointment, the professional accountant shall at least seek to contact the existing or predecessor accountant". It adds that the new accountant "will usually need the client’s permission, preferably in writing" to start those discussions. On records, it says that "an existing accountant shall deal promptly with any reasonable request for the transfer of records and may have the right of particular lien if there are unpaid fees". The code is on the ICAEW Code of Ethics page. Members of other bodies follow their own rules.
You can describe a typical handover in plain words (this is a practical summary, not a requirement of the code):
- The owner tells you they want to move and gives you permission to contact the current firm.
- You contact the current firm, as your rules require.
- Records and information move across, and you agree who handles which period.
If a deadline is close, it may be better to switch after it. Our accounting client onboarding checklist walks through each step once a client says yes.
What should you never say?
Never criticise the current accountant, even if the owner does. Apart from being bad manners, the professional codes are clear about marketing. The ICAEW Code says a professional accountant "shall be honest and truthful" and shall not make "exaggerated claims" or "disparaging references or unsubstantiated comparisons to the work of others". If you are unsure whether a message is appropriate, the code says the accountant "is encouraged to consult with the relevant professional body".
In the US, the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct says a member in public practice "shall not seek to obtain clients by advertising or other forms of solicitation in a manner that is false, misleading, or deceptive". The code is published by the AICPA.
These are quotes, not advice. Read your own professional body’s code before any outreach.
Also avoid price-only pitches, pressure on deadlines and asking them to leave today.
When should you let it go?
Some answers mean the owner is a good client of someone else. Close politely and leave the door open:
- They are happy and cannot name anything they would change.
- The accountant is a family member or close friend.
- They have just signed with a new firm.
Note the conversation and, where it is appropriate, a date to check in, for example after their next year-end. The aim is to be the obvious next call when circumstances change. For ways to stay visible without pushing, see how accounting firms get new clients and our accounting firm referral program guide.
Checklist: answering "we already have an accountant"
- Did you acknowledge that having an accountant is sensible?
- Did you ask about their business, not about the other firm?
- Did you listen for a recent change or an unmet need?
- Did you offer something small rather than a full proposal?
- Did you avoid any criticism or comparison with the current firm?
- Did you explain how a handover works if they fear the hassle?
- Did you agree a next step or a date to check in?
How should your first email anticipate the objection?
Say in your first message that they probably already have an accountant, and that you are writing about one specific topic. Our cold email template for accounting firms includes wording you can adapt, and our guide on how to write a cold email covers the structure.
Where does Arbyn Partners fit?
Arbyn Partners books meetings for B2B firms in the UK and the US, including accounting practices. The meetings are with business owners or decision-makers who have a real need, not a competitor or an existing client of yours. Many of those owners already have an accountant; what matters is that they have a need you can help with. You pay only for qualified meetings that take place: £150 in the UK and $200 in the US. The first qualified meeting is free, one per company, and there is no retainer. See our page on lead generation for accounting firms.
More about Arbyn Partners is on our homepage.
FAQ
What does "we already have an accountant" usually mean?
Most often it is a reflex to end a cold contact. Sometimes it means genuine satisfaction, habit, a personal relationship or fear that switching is too much hassle.
How should an accountant respond to "we already have an accountant"?
Acknowledge it, ask one question about their business, offer something small and agree a next step or a date to check in.
Should I criticise the prospect’s current accountant?
No. Professional codes such as the ICAEW Code say accountants shall not make disparaging references or unsubstantiated comparisons to the work of others.
How does switching accountants work in the UK?
Under the ICAEW Code, the new accountant seeks to contact the existing one, usually with the client’s written permission, and the existing accountant deals promptly with reasonable requests to transfer records.
When should I stop following up?
When the owner is happy and cannot name anything to change, the accountant is a close friend or family member, or they have just appointed a new firm.
Can Arbyn Partners book meetings with owners who already have an accountant?
Yes, if they have a real need you can help with and are not an existing client of yours. You pay £150 in the UK or $200 in the US per qualified meeting held, and the first one is free.